So the above map is something I did using paint and google maps.
The purple stars are the gas stations in 2004. at this time the highway was built as it is today so not much changed there. The red star is were I if I remember right the party was if not its just the opposite side of the road and not much change. 

As you can see you have 152 which is all paved, and the three gas stations are just off 152. the two in town may have been closed after midnight around 2004 but the one on the other side of the highway was placed there primarily for truckers and people coming off work from the powerplant.

In order for Justin to get lost going to get cigarettes, he would have had to turn off from 152 outside of town rather than go straight to the gas station. The Gas station in the center of town is a Co-op and mostly used by farmers, they wouldnt have had Cigs. The one on the far left was the Casy's location at the time (they have since moved.)

(if the Ciggerate story is something that has just been confuddled or a rumor over the passing years there needs to be a clear up of that.)
